CIHT brings highways professionals together to inform National Audit Office review of local road maintenance

16th Nov 2026

Local authority representatives shared their experiences of funding, transparency and the challenges of maintaining the UK’s road network, helping to inform the NAO’s follow-up work.

Get ahead with CIHT Membership

Join other savvy professionals just like you at CIHT.  We are  committed to fulfilling your professional development needs throughout your career

Find out more

CIHT has brought together local authority highways professionals for a focus group with the National Audit Office (NAO), providing an opportunity to share experiences of local road maintenance funding, transparency requirements and the challenges facing the sector.

The session will feed into the evidence gathering  for a follow-up to the NAO's 2024 review on The condition and maintenance of local roads in England which examined how the Department for Transport (DfT) supported local road maintenance, including the funding and wider guidance available to local highway authorities. The latest review will consider developments since 2024, including the introduction of multi-year funding settlements and the new transparency reporting regime. Details available at Update on local road maintenance - NAO work in progress.

Discussions explored how these changes are affecting local authorities in practice, what is working well and where further support is needed.

Longer-term funding certainty welcomed, but financial pressures remain

The introduction of a four-year funding settlement was widely welcomed for providing greater certainty and helping authorities plan maintenance programmes over a longer period.

However, participants highlighted that current funding levels remain insufficient to address the significant maintenance backlog across the local road network. Wider financial pressures, including reductions in local authority revenue budgets and competing demands on resources, are also limiting the ability to supplement central government funding.

Concerns were raised that, despite increases in DfT allocations, some authorities may have less overall funding available for highway maintenance in the coming years.

Transparency reporting brings benefits but questions remain over ratings

The transparency reporting regime was recognised as a positive development, helping authorities bring information together across different teams, improve organisational visibility of highway maintenance and communicate investment decisions to elected members.

Publishing information about asset condition, maintenance expenditure and planned works has also provided a useful evidence base for explaining decisions, particularly where preventative treatments are being prioritised over roads in the poorest condition.

However, concerns remain about the methodology used to determine the red, amber and green (RAG) ratings, with calls for greater transparency and earlier publication of results. Uncertainty around how ratings are calculated makes it difficult for authorities to understand their performance and use the findings to inform future maintenance programmes.

Participants also highlighted the risk that ratings could create unintended incentives, encouraging authorities to prioritise achieving a green rating over taking a balanced approach to managing their wider highway asset portfolios. Many authorities are responsible for assets beyond carriageways and structures, including drainage, street lighting, traffic signals, public rights of way and street furniture. There were concerns that focusing resources on the assets included in the reporting framework could come at the expense of other important infrastructure.

Preventative maintenance and innovation offer opportunities

The focus on preventative maintenance was identified as an important opportunity to improve the long-term management of the network and make better use of available funding.

Some authorities are already introducing new approaches, including micro-asphalt treatments, asphalt preservation and retexturing, alongside more established maintenance techniques.

However, participants emphasised that preventative maintenance needs to be supported by robust evidence and cost-benefit analysis. Treatments must be appropriate to the condition of the road, with more substantial structural interventions still required where deterioration is advanced.

There were also concerns about the performance of some newer treatments, highlighting the importance of sharing evidence, monitoring outcomes and understanding whole-life costs, including the additional preparation work that some preventative treatments require.

Developing the skills and knowledge needed to adopt new techniques was another important theme. Further training, technical guidance and opportunities to share good practice were identified as areas where national support could make a difference.

Structures and wider asset management present significant challenges

Maintaining highway structures remains a considerable challenge for local authorities, with ageing infrastructure, substantial maintenance backlogs and the high cost of major repairs placing pressure on already constrained budgets.

The Structures Fund was recognised as a useful mechanism for supporting major maintenance projects, but participants questioned whether the funding available is sufficient to address the scale of the challenge. There were calls for structures maintenance to receive more dedicated funding rather than competing directly with other highway maintenance requirements.
Improving asset data was also identified as a priority. In particular, gaps in information about drainage infrastructure make it difficult for authorities to understand the condition and extent of their assets, assess risks and prioritise investment. Greater support for research and data collection was highlighted as an important area for future government investment.

Devolution brings opportunities and uncertainty

The discussion also considered the implications of local government reorganisation and the expansion of strategic and mayoral authorities.

While greater regional coordination could create opportunities to take a more strategic approach to network management, combine resources and share expertise, participants highlighted concerns about the potential costs of reorganisation and the uncertainty surrounding future funding arrangements.

The relationship between strategic authorities and local highway authorities will be particularly important, including how funding is allocated and where technical expertise and decision-making responsibilities sit.

There was also recognition that different regions have varying levels of capacity and experience, making it important that future funding arrangements are fair and reflect local needs.

Supporting the sector through guidance, evidence and collaboration

Across the discussions, several areas emerged where the DfT could provide further support. These included clearer technical guidance, greater consistency in the application of maintenance standards, improved communication around performance ratings, investment in asset data and research, and better opportunities to identify and share good practice.

The focus group provided an opportunity for local authority professionals to share practical experiences and highlight how national policy and funding arrangements affect the delivery of highway maintenance on the ground. CIHT’s Preventative Highways Maintenance Fundamentals eLearning course was highlighted as a useful training resource for the sector.

The NAO is expected to publish its report in early 2027. CIHT will continue to support the sector by bringing together professional expertise and contributing to discussions about the long-term management, maintenance and resilience of the local road network.

Comments on this site are moderated. Please allow up to 24 hours for your comment to be published on this site. Thank you for adding your comment.
{{comments.length}}CommentComments
{{item.AuthorName}}

{{item.AuthorName}} {{item.AuthorName}} says on {{item.DateFormattedString}}:

Share
Email
Bookmark

Get ahead with CIHT Membership

Join other savvy professionals just like you at CIHT.  We are  committed to fulfilling your professional development needs throughout your career

Find out more