Attempts to derail High Speed 2 have failed in the High Court – but Government will have to re-run a consultation on providing compensation for property owners affected by the route.

Mr Justice Ouseley rejected nine challenges to phase one of the project between London and Birmingham, brought by four sets of claimants. But he did uphold a challenge that the consultation process with nearby householders was unfair due to lack of information provided and an inadequate explanation of how compensation options were considered.

Department for Transport was upbeat following the hearing, claiming “a landmark victory for HS2”. Minister for High Speed Rail Simon Burns said: “The judge has categorically given the green light for the Government to press ahead without delay in building a high speed railway from London to Birmingham, Manchester and Leeds. Nothing now stands in the way of taking our plans to Parliament.”

He acknowledged that the Department will reconsult on the property compensation consultation, but added “this will not delay HS2”.

Pressure group HS2 Action Alliance also claimed success following the ruling. Spokesman Hilary Wharf said: “Today’s judgement is a huge victory for the hundreds of thousands of people whose lives are blighted by HS2. The Government’s shabby attempt to railroad through an inadequate compensation scheme while ignoring the views of ordinary people have been judged to be unlawful.”

To return to the newsletter, please close this window.